Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
  • Call Now 1-888-891-0229
Medicare made easy

Compare Medicare plans & enroll online

New York Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: Community Rates, Year-Round Enrollment and Our DFS Price Math

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 19, 2026

New York Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 can be bought in any month, and each insurer charges every buyer in a region the same premium no matter their age or health. On the state’s October 2026 rate list, 9 insurers sell Plan G at $264.80 to $840.28 a month, so the company and region you pick matter far more than your birthday.

2027 by the Numbers

9

insurers (11 brand listings) on the NY DFS October 2026 rate comparison (our count)

$6,906

yearly spread between the lowest and highest Plan G rate in New York, October 2026 (our math)

10

rating regions set by ZIP code on the DFS list

$3,050

2027 deductible for high-deductible Plan G, called G+ in New York (CMS)

Most states let Medigap companies price by age and turn down sick applicants after the first six months. New York does neither, and its Department of Financial Services (DFS) posts every insurer’s premiums monthly in ten ZIP code regions.

We counted the companies on the list in effect October 1, 2026, worked out the price spreads and tested when a lower-premium plan pays off. For how the plan letters compare nationally, start with our Medicare Supplement plans 2027 overview.

Compare 2027 New York Medigap Prices

Advertisement

Why New York Shoppers Can Take Their Time (Within Limits)

New York Medicare Supplement plans 2027 year-round enrollment and waiting period steps

Two state rules shape every New York Medigap decision. First, open enrollment never closes. Anyone with Medicare Parts A and B can apply in any month, and the insurer cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health, past claims or age. Second, premiums are community rated: a company charges one price for a given plan in an area, whether you are 65, 75 or 90, male or female.

New York difference: Because age does not raise the price, a 65-year-old and an 85-year-old in the same region pay the same premium for the same policy, such as $336.25 a month for one UnitedHealthcare Plan G rate on the October 2026 DFS list. Waiting to buy does not lock in a higher age band.

The upside. You can switch companies or plan letters later without passing health questions, so a cheaper plan today is not a one-way door.

The catch. Starting prices are high, because younger buyers help pay for older ones.

The other catch. A late buyer with no recent coverage can face a waiting period of up to six months for pre-existing conditions.

Compare Medicare Supplement Plans

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Our Count: Who Is on the October 2026 DFS Rate List

The DFS comparison lists 11 brands from 9 insurers, because Excellus sells under both Excellus BlueCross BlueShield and Univera Healthcare, and Highmark sells as Blue Cross Blue Shield of Western New York and Blue Shield of Northeastern New York. Each figure below is the lowest and highest rate that brand shows across the regions it serves.

Insurer (brand)Plan GPlan NPlan G+ (high deductible)
Aetna Life$264.80-$406.26Not listedNot listed
UnitedHealthcare$336.25-$372.50$269.00-$299.00Not listed
Globe Life$384.00-$516.00$375.00-$504.00$76.00-$102.00
Mutual of Omaha$384.02-$511.36Not listedNot listed
EmblemHealth$393.72-$432.09$286.81-$314.77$61.67-$67.69
Excellus BCBS / Univera$477.04$481.97-$582.93$85.00
Highmark BCBS of WNY$497.43$318.24Not listed
Highmark BS of NNY$492.20$321.82Not listed
Bankers Conseco$579.94-$840.28$361.44-$523.54$52.53-$75.69
Humana$601.17-$709.98$426.20-$503.23$90.31-$106.34

Source: NY DFS, Comparison of Year 2026 Community Rated Standardized Medicare Supplement Monthly Premiums, in effect October 1, 2026. Ranges are our summary across regions; a rate may apply in part or all of a region.

All 11 brands sell Plan G, 9 sell Plan N and only 6 sell Plan G+. Aetna and Mutual of Omaha show no Plan N at all. For how these companies compare on service and history, see our best Medicare Supplement companies 2027 guide.

The Six-Month Pre-Existing Condition Wait, Step by Step

Year-round acceptance does not always mean day-one coverage for every condition. HIICAP materials explain the wait.

1

Check the look-back. A condition counts as pre-existing if a doctor gave advice or treatment for it in the six months before your policy starts.

2

Expect up to six months. An insurer may delay paying for that condition for up to six months after your start date.

3

Subtract prior coverage. New York makes insurers shorten the wait by your days of prior creditable coverage, such as an employer plan, Medicaid, TRICARE, VA care, Medicare Advantage or another Medigap, as long as the gap was 63 days or less.

4

Know the Medicare-only limit. If you are 65 or older, have had Parts A and B for more than six months and had no Medigap or other secondary coverage, Original Medicare alone earns no credit.

Your six-month federal window at 65 still matters for this reason. Our Medicare Supplement open enrollment 2027 page covers that window in detail.

Plan G, Plan N or Plan G+? Our Math on New York Rates

New York Medicare Supplement plans 2027 lowest Plan G monthly rate by insurer, DFS October 2026

New York’s high Plan G premiums make lower-premium plans worth testing. We used brands with one flat rate, so each test compares the same area.

Test (October 2026 DFS rates)Monthly premiumsYearly premium savingsWhat you give up
Excellus: Plan G vs. Plan G+$477.04 vs. $85.00$4,704.48You pay up to $3,050 in 2027 before G+ pays
Highmark WNY: Plan G vs. Plan N$497.43 vs. $318.24$2,150.28Copays up to $20 per office visit and $50 per ER visit
Excellus: Plan N vs. Plan G$481.97 and up vs. $477.04NonePlan N costs more and covers less

Our math from the NY DFS list in effect October 1, 2026. Rates can change before or during 2027.

G+ worst case. At Excellus, a full $3,050 deductible plus G+ premiums totals about $4,070 a year, versus about $6,016 for Plan G plus the $292 Part B deductible.

Plan N at Highmark. The $2,150 savings covers more than 100 office copays of $20.

Check the letter. At Excellus and Univera, Plan N is priced above Plan G, so Plan G is the better buy there.

New York also limits how much many doctors may bill above Medicare’s approved amount under Public Health Law Section 19, with an exception for office and home visits, which lowers the risk of the excess charges Plan N leaves uncovered. Compare benefits in our Plan G vs. Plan N and high-deductible Plan G 2027 guides.

Compare plans now!

Advertisement

Need Help?

1-888-891-0229TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-8pm EST

Ten ZIP Code Regions and Medicare Before 65

DFS regionFirst 3 ZIP digits
NYC Proper100-104, 111-114
Long Island110, 115-119
Westchester105-109
Mid-Hudson124-127
Albany120-123, 128-129
Utica133-135
Syracuse130-132, 137-139, 148-149
Watertown136
Rochester144-146
Buffalo140-143, 147

Source: NY DFS rate comparison, October 2026. Some brands sell in only part of the state; the Highmark brands list rates in two or three regions.

Under 65 on Medicare: New York’s age rule applies to people who get Medicare early due to disability or kidney failure. They can buy any plan an insurer sells in their area, in any month, at the same community rate a 65-year-old pays.

What 2027 May Bring for New York Premiums

Each insurer asks DFS for its own changes. EmblemHealth, for example, proposed a 6.22% increase for Plans A, G, G+ and N effective January 1, 2027 or the renewal date, whichever is later. DFS can approve, change or deny such requests. See our Medicare Supplement rate increases 2027 page for the national picture.

2027 Medicare figureAmountStatus
Part B premium$209.40 a monthCMS, Nov. 17, 2026
Part B deductible$292CMS, Nov. 17, 2026
Part A deductible$1,776CMS, Nov. 17, 2026
Plan G+ / high-deductible deductible$3,050Set by CMS
Plan K / Plan L out-of-pocket limits$8,360 / $4,180Set by CMS

CMS announced the final 2027 Part A and B amounts on November 17, 2026.

30-day free look. You can return a new New York policy within 30 days of getting it for a full refund.

No Medicare SELECT. HIICAP reports that no insurer currently sells Medicare SELECT network plans in New York.

Free counseling. HIICAP, run by the NY State Office for the Aging, offers free, unbiased Medicare help statewide.

Bottom Line

In New York you can buy or switch a Medicare Supplement plan any month, and age never raises the price. The real decision is the company and region: the October 2026 DFS list shows Plan G from $264.80 to $840.28 a month, and Plan G+ can save thousands for people who can cover a $3,050 deductible.

See 2027 Medigap premiums for your New York ZIP code

Advertisement

New York Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Does my New York Medigap premium go up as I get older?

Not because of age. New York requires community rating, so an insurer charges the same premium for a plan in a region regardless of age, sex or health. Premiums can still rise when DFS approves a company-wide increase.

➤ Can I be turned down for a Medigap plan in New York?

No. Anyone with Medicare Parts A and B can buy a plan in any month, and insurers cannot reject you for health reasons. They may apply a waiting period of up to six months for pre-existing conditions if you lack recent coverage.

➤ Which companies sell Plan G in New York?

The October 2026 DFS list shows Plan G from Aetna, Bankers Conseco, EmblemHealth, Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, Univera Healthcare, Globe Life, two Highmark Blue brands, Humana, Mutual of Omaha and UnitedHealthcare.

➤ What is Plan G+ in New York?

Plan G+ is the state’s name for high-deductible Plan G. You pay the first $3,050 of covered costs in 2027, then it pays like Plan G. Six brands sell it, at $52.53 to $106.34 a month on the October 2026 list.

➤ Where does New York publish Medigap rates?

The Department of Financial Services posts a monthly comparison of every insurer’s community-rated premiums by region, plus an online rate look-up by ZIP code.

➤ Can I get Medigap in New York before 65?

Yes. People under 65 on Medicare because of disability or kidney failure can buy any plan sold in their area, any month, at the same rate older members pay.

➤ Is Plan N cheaper than Plan G everywhere in New York?

No. At Excellus and Univera, Plan N rates on the October 2026 list start at $481.97, above their $477.04 Plan G rate. At most other brands, Plan N costs less.

➤ Will New York Medigap rates change in 2027?

Likely, but each insurer files separately. EmblemHealth has proposed a 6.22% increase for Plan G and Plan N starting January 2027, pending DFS review.

Compare Medicare Supplement Plans

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-888-891-0229

No obligation to enroll

Compare plans now!

Advertisement

Need Help?

1-888-891-0229TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-8pm EST

About Us | Editorial Policy | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Contact Us

This website and the Medicare Supplement insurance plans referenced on it are not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance is sold by private insurance companies. CompareMedicareSupplementPlans.org is a website owned and operated by ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company and licensed insurance agency. We do not offer every plan or insurance company available in your area; any information we provide is limited to the plans and companies we represent.

Plan availability, benefits and premiums vary by state, age, gender, tobacco use, ZIP code and insurance company, and are subject to underwriting where permitted by law. Rates and figures shown on this site may reflect 2026 data and 2027 projections and are for informational purposes only; your actual premium will be determined by the insurance company. You must continue to pay your Medicare Part B premium. Medicare Supplement plans are not Medicare Advantage plans and do not include prescription drug coverage.

By submitting your information in the form, you agree to this site's privacy policy and expressly consent to be contacted at the number entered in the form (including a wireless number if provided) by licensed insurance agents or other partners offering related products that may be of interest to you, by phone, email or text. You understand that these calls may be generated using an automatic telephone dialing system, a pre-recorded message or artificial voice, or by sending SMS messages. Your telephone company may impose additional charges for such messages. You understand that you are not required to provide this consent to purchase goods or services. Receiving quotes through our website is always free, and you are under no obligation to purchase any goods or services as a result of this request.

For information on all of your Medicare options, contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY users should call 1-877-486-2048) 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, or your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP).