Best Medicare Supplement Companies 2027: A Scorecard Built From State Rate Filings
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 1, 2026
For 2027, Humana and Medico (Wellabe) priced Plan G lowest among the major companies we scored on Maryland’s July 2026 rate guide, while Mutual of Omaha holds the strongest AM Best rating, A+ (Superior). Every Medigap plan letter pays the same benefits at every company, so the best company for you is the one with a strong rating, a fair price at your age and a steady rate history.
2027 by the Numbers
A+
Mutual of Omaha’s AM Best rating, the only A+ (Superior) among the six groups we scored (AM Best, April 2026)
$231
Medico’s Plan G for a 75-year-old man, lowest of 25 companies in Maryland’s July 2026 guide
9 of 18
companies on New Jersey’s age-65 chart that raised Plan G between April and September 2026 (our math)
$105.56
monthly gap between the lowest and highest Plan G among our six groups in NJ, September 2026 (our math)
Because Medicare standardizes what each Medigap letter pays, a Plan G from one company covers exactly what a Plan G from another covers. The real differences are price, financial strength and how fast premiums climb. Most “best company” lists skip those numbers.
We scored six company groups that sell widely using three public sources: AM Best ratings, New Jersey’s September 2026 Plan G chart and Maryland’s July 2026 rate guide. To pick a plan letter first, see our best Medicare Supplement plans for 2027.
Compare 2027 Rates From These Companies
The Three Things That Separate Companies

Financial strength. An AM Best rating shows a company’s ability to pay claims for decades. Every group we scored is rated A (Excellent) or better.
Price at your age. Each company sets its own rates by age, sex, ZIP code and tobacco use, and the cheapest at 65 is often not the cheapest at 75.
Rate behavior. A low entry price means little if the company raises it sharply. State charts let you see changes over time.
Claims service matters less with Medigap than with other insurance, because Medicare decides what is covered and most claims are paid automatically through crossover. That is why our scorecard leans on numbers rather than brand reputation.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
Our 2027 Scorecard: Ratings and State Prices
We pulled each group’s Plan G price for a non-tobacco man from two official sources and ranked it against every company on the same chart.
| Company group | AM Best | NJ Plan G, 65 (rank of 19) | MD Plan G, 65 (rank of 25) | MD Plan G, 75 (rank of 25) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Humana | A (Excellent) | $210.01 (8th) | $205 (2nd) | $258 (3rd) |
| Medico / Wellabe | A (Excellent) | $207.42 (6th) | $215 (4th, tied) | $231 (1st) |
| HealthSpring (former Cigna Medigap) | A (Excellent) | $214.14 (9th) | $241 (10th) | $315 (10th) |
| Blue Cross plans (Horizon NJ, CareFirst MD) | Varies by plan | $194.32 (3rd) | $249 (14th) | $382 (21st) |
| Mutual of Omaha | A+ (Superior) | $228.02 (14th) | $278 (20th) | $369 (19th) |
| Aetna | A (Excellent) | $299.88 (19th) | $300 (24th) | $375 (20th) |
Sources: NJ Division of Aging Services, Male Preferred Rates at Age 65, September 2026; Maryland Insurance Administration rate guide, rates as of July 1, 2026 (male preferred or non-tobacco; CareFirst Level 1, Baltimore metro). Humana NJ row is its Achieve rate. Ranks are our math.
Reading the table: Humana and Medico land near the top in both states, Aetna near the bottom. Mutual of Omaha trades a higher price for the top rating. Blue Cross results depend entirely on which Blue company serves your state.
Who Raised Plan G Prices in 2026
New Jersey publishes its chart several times a year, so we compared the April 2026 and September 2026 male age-65 Plan G prices for the same companies. A change here reflects the price a new 65-year-old buyer pays.
| Company (NJ, man 65) | April 2026 | September 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Humana (Achieve) | $210.01 | $210.01 | No change |
| Aetna | $299.88 | $299.88 | No change |
| Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of NJ | $194.32 | $194.32 | No change |
| Medico | $190.29 | $207.42 | +9.0% |
| United World Life (Mutual of Omaha group) | $198.28 | $228.02 | +15.0% |
| HealthSpring | $181.47 | $214.14 | +18.0% |
Our comparison of NJ Division of Aging Services charts dated April 2026 and September 2026. Existing policyholders’ increases follow each company’s filing and renewal dates, which can differ.
Across all 18 companies listed on both charts, nine left Plan G unchanged over those five months and nine raised it, with a median increase of 15% among the nine that did. One snapshot does not predict 2027, but it does show which companies moved.
Company Notes for 2027 Shoppers

Mutual of Omaha. Sells in every state except Massachusetts and offers a 7% or 12% household discount depending on the state. See our Mutual of Omaha 2027 review.
Humana. Its rating was affirmed at A (Excellent), stable outlook, on December 16, 2025, and it priced Plan G near the bottom in Maryland. Details in our Humana Medicare Supplement guide.
Medico / Wellabe. Sells in about 28 states. Its Maryland Plan G rose only $16 a month from age 65 to 75, the flattest age curve of the six.
HealthSpring. The former Cigna Medigap business, now owned by HCSC, advertises household discounts up to 25% in some states but none in Hawaii, Idaho, Minnesota or Vermont.
Aetna’s policies come from CVS Health insurance companies rated A (Excellent), and many states offer a household discount, often 7%. Blue Cross Medigap is sold by separate local companies, so price and rules change at the state line.
Why Price at 75 Matters More Than Price at 65
Most companies use attained-age pricing, so premiums step up as you age on top of any yearly rate changes. Maryland’s guide prints prices at several ages, which lets us measure the climb.
| Company (MD, man) | Plan G at 65 | Plan G at 75 | Increase from age alone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medico / Wellabe | $215 | $231 | +7% |
| Humana | $205 | $258 | +26% |
| Aetna | $300 | $375 | +25% |
| HealthSpring | $241 | $315 | +31% |
| Mutual of Omaha | $278 | $369 | +33% |
| CareFirst (Level 1) | $249 | $382 | +53% |
Maryland Insurance Administration rate guide, rates as of July 1, 2026. Percentages are our math and exclude future rate changes.
A company that starts $10 cheaper at 65 can end up more than $100 a month dearer by 75. Ask every company for its price at your current age and at ages 70 and 75.
How to Choose Your Company in 2027
Pick the plan letter. Settle on Plan G, Plan N or High-Deductible G before comparing companies.
Shortlist A-rated companies. All six groups here qualify; skip unrated or weakly rated names.
Compare price at three ages. Request quotes at your age and five and ten years older.
Check household discounts. A 7% to 12% discount can reorder the list if you live with another adult.
Look at recent changes. Ask what the company’s last two rate changes were in your state.
Healthy buyers past their open enrollment window will answer health questions, so apply with the company you want most first.
Bottom Line
No single company is best everywhere. On 2026 state filings, Humana and Medico offered the lowest major-company Plan G prices, Mutual of Omaha carried the strongest rating, and HealthSpring and Mutual of Omaha raised NJ prices the most this year. Compare at least three A-rated companies at your age and older ages before you choose.
Get 2027 Plan G and Plan N prices for your age and ZIP code
Best Medicare Supplement Companies 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ Which Medicare Supplement company has the highest AM Best rating?
Among the six groups we scored, Mutual of Omaha is the only one rated A+ (Superior). The others are rated A (Excellent), which is still a strong rating.
➤ Does a more expensive company give better Plan G coverage?
No. Plan G benefits are set by federal rules, so a $300 Plan G pays the same bills as a $200 Plan G.
➤ Which company had the lowest Plan G price in Maryland?
In the July 2026 guide, Monitor Life of New York had the lowest age-65 price at $203, with Humana close behind at $205. At age 75, Medico was lowest at $231.
➤ Is HealthSpring the same as Cigna?
HealthSpring now runs the Medigap business Cigna sold to HCSC, so many former Cigna policies carry the HealthSpring name.
➤ Why do companies charge different prices for the same plan?
Each company prices its own pool of policyholders, ages and claims, and state regulators review the filings.
➤ Should I choose the cheapest company?
Only if its rating is strong and its price stays competitive at older ages. Compare its age 70 and 75 prices too.
➤ How do household discounts change the ranking?
A 7% to 25% discount, where offered, can move a mid-priced company ahead of a cheaper one if you live with a spouse or other adult.
➤ Can I switch companies later if my rates go up?
Yes, but outside your open enrollment window or a state switching rule you will usually answer health questions.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

