Ohio Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: Licensed Insurers, the Balance-Billing Ban and Plan N Math
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026
Ohio Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 are sold by the 33 insurers on the Ohio Department of Insurance’s current Medicare 101 list, and Plan G is the plan most Ohio members choose. Ohio law also bars Ohio-licensed doctors from billing Medicare patients above Medicare’s approved amount, which changes the usual Plan G vs. Plan N trade-off.
2027 by the Numbers
33
Medigap insurers on the Ohio Dept. of Insurance 2026 Medicare 101 list (our count)
53%
Ohio Medigap members on Plan G, end of 2024 (NAIC data via NerdWallet)
68.5%
Ohio members held by the top three insurers (our math, same NAIC data)
$292
2027 Part B deductible, paid under both Plan G and Plan N (CMS)
Ohio does not publish a Medigap price chart. The Department of Insurance names the licensed companies in its Medicare 101 booklet and sends shoppers to OSHIIP, its free counseling program, for price comparisons.
This guide counts that list, explains an Ohio statute most shopping guides skip, and runs the Plan G versus Plan N numbers with the 2027 Part B deductible. If you are still deciding between Original Medicare with a supplement and a private plan, read our Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement 2027 comparison first.
See 2027 Ohio Medigap Prices
Who Insures Ohio's Medigap Members Today

More than 600,000 Ohioans hold a Medicare Supplement policy, according to AHIP figures cited by NerdWallet. Membership is concentrated: three companies hold about two of every three Ohio policies.
| Insurer | Share of Ohio Medigap members | Note |
|---|---|---|
| UnitedHealthcare | 38.0% | Largest national Medigap writer |
| Medical Mutual of Ohio | 19.3% | Headquartered in Cleveland |
| Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield | 11.2% | Listed by the state as Community Insurance Company |
| Humana | 5.7% | Two Humana entries on the state list |
| Mutual of Omaha | 5.4% | Listed as Omaha Supplemental Insurance |
Market shares: NAIC data for year-end 2024 as reported by NerdWallet. Top-three total (68.5%) is our math.
About 53% of Ohio members hold Plan G, 28% hold Plan F and 13% hold Plan N, so those three letters cover roughly 94% of the market. Plan F remains only for people eligible for Medicare before 2020. Our Medicare Supplement Plan G 2027 page covers the most popular choice in detail.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
Our Count of the State's Licensed-Insurer List
The Department of Insurance’s 2026 Medicare 101 booklet, posted as its April 2026 version, lists the companies licensed to sell Medigap in Ohio. We counted 33 entries. The department’s Medicare 101 web page still shows an older list of 59 names.
Two Ohio-based companies. Medical Mutual of Ohio (Cleveland) and AultCare (Canton) are the only Ohio-headquartered insurers on the list.
One Blue Cross plan. Anthem appears under its Ohio company name, Community Insurance Company.
Familiar national names. UnitedHealthcare, Aetna (Continental Life), Cigna, Humana, Mutual of Omaha, State Farm and USAA Life all appear.
Smaller specialists. Everence, WoodmenLife, Pekin and Erie Family Life round out the field.
Reading the list: A company on the state list is licensed to sell Medigap in Ohio, but each insurer chooses its own plan letters and service areas. A ZIP-code quote shows which ones actually sell where you live.
Ohio's Balance-Billing Ban: The Statute Most Guides Skip
Federal rules let a doctor who does not accept assignment charge up to 15% above Medicare’s approved amount, the Part B excess charge. Ohio goes further. Ohio Revised Code 4769.02 says no health care practitioner, and no employer of one, may balance bill a Medicare beneficiary. Section 4769.01 defines balance billing as charging or collecting more than the Medicare reimbursement rate, other than Medicare deductibles and coinsurance, and the rule does not apply when Medicare is the secondary payer.
Who is covered. The law lists 19 types of practitioners, including physicians, dentists, chiropractors, optometrists, psychologists and therapists.
How to complain. Complaints go to the Ohio Department of Health under section 4769.03.
Repayment. The department can order the practitioner to refund the overcharge with interest from the date you paid.
Penalties. A first violation can bring a $500 penalty, with $2,000 more for each later violation.
Where the protection ends: The statute is Ohio law. Care received from a provider in another state follows that state’s rules and the federal 15% limit, so excess-charge coverage still has some value for people who see specialists outside Ohio.
Plan G or Plan N in Ohio: Our Break-Even Math

Plan N normally differs from Plan G in three ways: copays of up to $20 at some office visits, up to $50 at the emergency room when you are not admitted, and no coverage of Part B excess charges. With the balance-billing ban, the third difference mostly disappears for in-state care. The 2027 Part B deductible of $292 is paid under both plans, so it cancels out of the comparison.
| Plan N saves you | Yearly savings | Office copays to break even | With one $50 ER copay |
|---|---|---|---|
| $20 a month | $240 | 12 visits | 9 visits |
| $30 a month | $360 | 18 visits | 15 visits |
| $40 a month | $480 | 24 visits | 21 visits |
| $50 a month | $600 | 30 visits | 27 visits |
Our math: yearly premium savings divided by the $20 maximum office copay, assuming every visit carries the full copay. Savings levels are examples; use your own Ohio quotes.
At $30 a month in savings, it takes more than 18 copay visits a year before Plan G costs less. For more at both letters, see our Plan G vs. Plan N guide.
Under 65, Switching and Guaranteed Rights in Ohio
Your strongest window in Ohio is the federal six-month Medigap open enrollment that begins with your Part B start date at 65 or older. During it, insurers cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health. Timing details are in our Medicare Supplement open enrollment 2027 guide.
| Situation | Ohio rule |
|---|---|
| Under 65 with disability or ESRD | No state requirement to sell Medigap (NAIC state chart). House Bill 24, introduced in the 136th General Assembly, would add one but sits in the House Insurance Committee. |
| Birthday or anniversary switching | Ohio has no state birthday or anniversary rule. |
| Losing employer or group coverage | Federal guaranteed-issue right, generally ending 63 days after coverage ends. |
| Leaving a first Medicare Advantage plan within 12 months | Federal trial-right protection lets you return to Medigap. |
Sources: NAIC Medigap open enrollment rights chart; Ohio House HB 24 status page; Ohio Dept. of Insurance Medicare 101.
Changing policies outside a window: Insurers may ask health questions and can decline an application. Keeping the current policy until the new one is approved in writing avoids a gap in coverage.
2027 Medicare Amounts and Free OSHIIP Counseling
| 2027 Medicare amount | Figure | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Part B premium | $209.40 a month | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| Part B deductible | $292 | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| Part A deductible | $1,776 | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| High-deductible Plan G deductible | $3,050 | Set by CMS |
| Plan K / Plan L out-of-pocket limit | $8,360 / $4,180 | Set by CMS |
CMS announced the 2027 Part A and Part B amounts on November 17, 2026.
The Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program, part of the Department of Insurance, has counseled Ohioans on Medicare since 1992. Its counselors give free, unbiased help, including personalized Medigap comparisons. If a lower monthly cost matters most, our Medicare Supplement Plan A 2027 page explains the most basic plan every insurer must offer.
Bottom Line
Ohio shoppers can choose from 33 licensed Medigap insurers, led by UnitedHealthcare, Medical Mutual of Ohio and Anthem. Because Ohio law bars in-state balance billing, Plan N gives up less than it does in many states, so compare its savings against your expected copays.
Price Ohio Plan G and Plan N for your ZIP code
Ohio Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ How many insurance companies sell Medigap in Ohio?
The Ohio Department of Insurance’s 2026 Medicare 101 booklet lists 33 companies licensed to sell Medicare Supplement plans. Each one picks its own plan letters and service areas.
➤ Which Medigap insurer has the most members in Ohio?
UnitedHealthcare held about 38% of Ohio Medigap members at the end of 2024, followed by Medical Mutual of Ohio at 19.3% and Anthem at 11.2%, based on NAIC data.
➤ Can an Ohio doctor charge me more than Medicare allows?
Not under Ohio Revised Code 4769.02, which bars health care practitioners from balance billing Medicare patients. Complaints go to the Ohio Department of Health, which can order a refund with interest.
➤ Do I need Plan G’s excess-charge coverage in Ohio?
It matters less for care from Ohio practitioners because of the state ban. It can still help if you see doctors in another state who do not accept Medicare assignment.
➤ Is Plan N a good value in Ohio?
Often. Divide your yearly Plan N savings by $20 to find the copay visits needed before Plan G costs less.
➤ Can I get a Medicare Supplement plan in Ohio before age 65?
Ohio does not currently require insurers to sell Medigap to people under 65. House Bill 24 would change that, but it had not passed as of this writing.
➤ Does Ohio let me switch Medigap plans on my birthday?
No. Ohio has no birthday or anniversary rule, so switching outside a federal guaranteed-issue right usually means answering health questions.
➤ Who gives free Medicare advice in Ohio?
OSHIIP, the Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program within the Department of Insurance, offers free and unbiased counseling, including Medigap comparisons.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

