Illinois Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: Birthday Rule, Chicago vs. Downstate Prices
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 2, 2026
Illinois Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 come with a yearly birthday rule: if you are 65 to 75 and already have a policy, you get 45 days starting on your birthday to move to an equal or smaller plan with the same insurer, with no health questions. Plan G is the most common choice, held by about 53% of Illinois Medigap members at the end of 2025.
2027 by the Numbers
760,120
Illinois Medigap enrollees, Dec. 31, 2025 (Mark Farrah Associates, NAIC data)
52.5%
share of those enrollees on Plan G, vs. 45.8% nationally (same report)
45 days
yearly birthday-rule window for ages 65 to 75 (215 ILCS 5/363)
$226 a year
Chicago-area premium over downstate for the same BCBSIL Plan G, man 65 (our math)
Illinois gives Medigap buyers something most states do not: a second chance every year. Since January 1, 2022, state law has let people ages 65 through 75 change to a plan with equal or fewer benefits from their current insurer during a 45-day window that opens on their birthday. That rule changes how you should pick a plan the first time.
Illinois also sets a ceiling on what people under 65 can be charged, and prices differ noticeably between the six Chicago-area counties and the rest of the state. If you are new to the plan letters, our Medicare Supplement plans 2027 guide covers them first.
Compare 2027 Illinois Plan G and N Rates
How the Illinois Birthday Rule Works in Practice

The rule sits in the Illinois Insurance Code, 215 ILCS 5/363(8), added by Public Act 102-142. It applies to anyone at least 65 and no older than 75 who already holds a Medicare Supplement policy. During the 45 days that begin on your birthday each year, your insurer must let you buy any of its Medicare Supplement policies with benefits equal to or lesser than what you have now. It cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health.
Check your age. You qualify from 65 through 75. At 76 the yearly window closes for good.
Mark your birthday. The 45 days start on your birthday itself, not the first of your birth month.
Ask your current insurer for its plan list. The statute says the same issuer. A 2024 bill (SB2910) to add affiliated companies did not pass.
Pick equal or fewer benefits. Plan G to Plan N or high-deductible G works. Plan N to Plan G does not, because G covers more.
Apply inside the window. Miss day 45 and you wait a year, or answer health questions.
Read this before you rely on it: Some national summaries say Illinois lets you move to an affiliate of your insurer. The statute text says the same issuer only. Confirm in writing with the insurer before you cancel anything.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
What Illinois Plan G and Plan N Cost: Chicago Area vs. the Rest of the State
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Illinois files two separate rate tables: one for Cook, DuPage, Kane, Lake, McHenry and Will counties, and one for the rest of the state. Its published outline of coverage shows how much location alone moves the price of the same plan.
| BCBSIL, age 65, non-tobacco | Chicago 6-county area | Rest of Illinois | Gap per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan G, man | $188.18 | $169.36 | $225.84 |
| Plan G, woman | $163.72 | $147.34 | $196.56 |
| Plan N, man | $137.95 | $124.14 | $165.72 |
| Plan N, woman | $120.00 | $108.00 | $144.00 |
Source: BCBSIL individual Medicare Supplement outlines of coverage, rates effective April 1, 2025, monthly. Gap column is our math. Newer rates may apply; quotes for 2027 can differ. BCBSIL does not list a high-deductible Plan G in these tables.
Two more patterns stand out. A man pays about 15% more than a woman for the same BCBSIL Plan G, and a tobacco user pays $207.00 in the Chicago area, $18.82 a month above the non-tobacco rate. For a broader look at the two plan letters, see Plan G vs. Plan N.
Using the Birthday Rule to Trim Your Premium: Our Math
Because Illinois lets you step down once a year, buying Plan G at 65 is a lower-risk choice here than in most states. If Plan G later feels too expensive, the birthday window can move you to Plan N with the same company without medical underwriting.
| Move made in the birthday window | Monthly premium change | Yearly premium change | New costs you take on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan G to Plan N, Chicago area, man 65 | -$50.23 | -$602.76 | Copays up to $20 per office visit and up to $50 per ER visit, plus Part B excess charges |
| Plan G to Plan N, downstate, man 65 | -$45.22 | -$542.64 | Same Plan N copays |
| Plan G to Plan N, Chicago area, woman 65 | -$43.72 | -$524.64 | Same Plan N copays |
Our math from the BCBSIL April 2025 rate tables above. Savings at older ages will differ; ask your insurer for its current rates by age.
Few doctor visits? Plan N’s copays rarely add up to $500 a year, so the step down can pay off.
Frequent specialist care? Copays and possible excess charges can erase the savings. Staying on Plan G may be smarter.
Over 75? The window is gone, so any change after that means passing health questions.
Under 65 With Medicare in Illinois: A Price Ceiling

Federal law does not make insurers sell Medigap to people under 65. Illinois does. Under 215 ILCS 5/363(6), an insurer cannot deny a policy to someone under 65 who has Medicare because of a disability, as long as they apply within six months of enrolling in Part B, and every plan type sold to people 65 and older must also be offered to them.
Illinois also caps the price. An under-65 premium cannot be higher than the insurer’s highest rate on its current filed schedule for that same plan for people 65 and older. Prices are still higher than an age-65 rate, but not open-ended as in some states. The statute speaks to disability; if your Medicare is based only on kidney failure, ask the insurer or the state before you assume the same rights.
At 65: Turning 65 opens a fresh six-month Medigap open enrollment. That is the time to re-shop at standard age-65 prices without health questions.
Plan Mix in Illinois Compared With the Nation
Illinois buyers lean toward Plan G and Plan F more heavily than the country as a whole, and use Plan N far less. Plan F is closed to anyone who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, so its share will keep shrinking.
| Plan | Illinois members | Illinois share | U.S. share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan G | 399,327 | 52.5% | 45.8% |
| Plan F | 273,354 | 36.0% | 30.2% |
| Plan N | 65,712 | 8.6% | 11.0% |
Source: Mark Farrah Associates, December 2025 Medigap Enrollment and Market Share (NAIC Medicare Supplement experience data), published May 2026. Shares are of enrollees with a reported plan type.
The market is concentrated: the largest carrier holds about 47% of Illinois Medigap members, according to the same report. Medicare SELECT policies, which use a hospital network in exchange for a lower price, are also filed in Illinois. Our list of top Medicare Supplement companies for 2027 compares the national carriers.
2027 Costs Your Illinois Plan Will and Won't Cover
| 2027 Medicare cost | Amount | Plan G | Plan N |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part B premium (2027) | $209.50 a month | You pay | You pay |
| Part B deductible (2027) | $292 | You pay | You pay |
| Part A hospital deductible (projected) | $1,788 | Covered | Covered |
| High-deductible Plan G deductible | $3,050 | Applies only to HD-G | Not applicable |
Part A and Part B 2027 amounts are Medicare Trustees projections; CMS announces final figures in the fall. HD-G deductible per CMS.
Free, unbiased counseling is available from the Illinois Senior Health Insurance Program (SHIP), run by the Illinois Department on Aging since 2013. For timing rules that apply in every state, read our Medicare Supplement open enrollment 2027 guide.
Bottom Line
Illinois is one of the friendlier states for Medigap buyers: a yearly birthday window from 65 to 75 and a price cap for people under 65. Location matters too, with Chicago-area prices running roughly 11% above downstate for the same plan. Compare insurers carefully at the start, because the birthday rule only lets you step down with the company you choose.
Check 2027 Medicare Supplement prices for your Illinois ZIP code
Illinois Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ Does Illinois have a Medigap birthday rule in 2027?
Yes. Illinois law gives people ages 65 through 75 who already have a Medicare Supplement policy 45 days each year, starting on their birthday, to buy a policy with equal or lesser benefits from the same insurer without health questions.
➤ Can I switch to a different company under the Illinois birthday rule?
Not under the statute. The law refers to the same issuer. A bill to add affiliated companies did not pass, so switching to another company still usually means medical underwriting.
➤ Can I move from Plan N up to Plan G during my birthday window?
No. The rule only covers plans with equal or fewer benefits than your current policy. Plan G covers more than Plan N, so that change requires health questions.
➤ Why do Chicago residents pay more for Medigap?
Insurers price by rating area. BCBSIL charges more in Cook, DuPage, Kane, Lake, McHenry and Will counties than downstate, about $226 a year more for a 65-year-old man on Plan G based on its 2025 tables.
➤ Can I get a Medicare Supplement plan in Illinois if I am under 65?
Yes, if you have Medicare due to a disability and apply within six months of starting Part B. Insurers must offer you the same plan types sold to people 65 and older, at a premium no higher than their highest filed rate for that plan.
➤ Which Medicare Supplement plan is most popular in Illinois?
Plan G. About 52.5% of Illinois Medigap members were on Plan G at the end of 2025, compared with 45.8% nationally.
➤ Are Medicare SELECT plans sold in Illinois?
Yes. Medicare SELECT policies are filed in Illinois. They cost less because you use network hospitals for non-emergency care.
➤ Where can I get free Medigap help in Illinois?
The Senior Health Insurance Program (SHIP), run by the Illinois Department on Aging, offers free one-on-one counseling. You can also compare insurer quotes for your ZIP code with a licensed agent.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

