New Jersey Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: State Rate Chart, Our Cost Math and Under-65 Plan D
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 19, 2026
New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 are sold by 18 companies on the state’s September 2026 rate chart, where Plan G for a 65-year-old man runs $164.31 to $299.88 a month. Plan N runs $119.90 to $200.84 and high-deductible Plan G $50.83 to $92.08 on the same New Jersey chart, so the company you pick matters as much as the plan letter.
2027 by the Numbers
$1,627
yearly gap between the lowest and highest Plan G premium, man 65, NJ September 2026 chart (our math)
18
companies with rates on the NJ Division of Aging Services September 2026 chart (our count)
11 of 18
of those companies that list high-deductible Plan G (our count)
$3,050
high-deductible Plan G deductible for 2027 (CMS)
New Jersey is one of the few states that prints Medigap prices side by side. Its State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), part of the NJ Division of Aging Services, posts monthly age-65 premiums for every filing company. The September 2026 edition, revised August 26, 2026, drives everything below.
We used it to measure the price gaps, test when Plan N or high-deductible Plan G pays off, and flag a Newark ZIP code rule. Still weighing Medigap against a private plan? See our Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement 2027 comparison.
See 2027 New Jersey Medigap Prices
Our Math: How Far Apart New Jersey Companies Price the Same Plan

Federal law fixes what each plan letter pays, so every New Jersey Plan G covers the same bills. Only the price and the company differ, and the gap is wide.
| Plan (man 65) | Lowest monthly | Highest monthly | Middle rate | Yearly gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan G | $164.31 | $299.88 | $222.72 | $1,626.84 |
| Plan N | $119.90 | $200.84 | $149.49 | $971.28 |
| High-deductible Plan G | $50.83 | $92.08 | $66.04 | $495.00 |
Our math from the NJ September 2026 chart (NJ Division of Aging Services, SHIP, male age 65 preferred rates). Middle rate is the median of all rate rows for that plan. Yearly gap = (highest minus lowest) x 12.
Reading the chart: Chart rates are age-65 starting prices for applicants who qualify for preferred rates. Older applicants get quotes from the company directly.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
Every Company on the September 2026 New Jersey Chart
The chart lists 21 rate rows from 18 companies, because UnitedHealthcare and Humana each file two versions and Philadelphia American Life prices by zone. Rows are sorted by Plan G price.
| Company | Plan G | Plan N | HD Plan G |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bankers Life (Washington National) | $164.31 | $119.90 | $56.26 |
| Bankers Fidelity | $172.82 | $131.58 | $57.02 |
| Horizon BCBS of New Jersey | $194.32 | $152.23 | Not listed |
| Insurance Company of North America | $200.25 | $136.89 | $71.58 |
| LifeShield National | $207.02 | $137.83 | Not listed |
| Medico | $207.42 | $144.45 | $71.56 |
| American Benefit Life | $207.72 | $149.49 | Not listed |
| Humana (Achieve) | $210.01 | $149.94 | $66.04 |
| HealthSpring National | $214.14 | $122.56 | $92.08 |
| Lumos | $222.72 | $146.53 | $77.91 |
| Humana (Value) | $225.16 | $128.14 | $53.49 |
| ManhattanLife | $226.00 | $169.00 | Not listed |
| AFLAC (Tier One) | $226.18 | $148.70 | Not listed |
| United World Life (Mutual of Omaha) | $228.02 | $159.23 | $58.51 |
| WoodmenLife | $236.09 | $163.33 | $80.53 |
| UnitedHealthcare | $237.23 | $128.53 | Not listed |
| UnitedHealthcare (Wellness Extras) | $243.92 | $186.80 | Not listed |
| United American | $282.00 | $200.00 | $89.00 |
| Aetna Health | $299.88 | $200.84 | Not listed |
| Philadelphia American Life | Not listed | $182.15-$200.37 | $50.83-$55.91 |
Source: NJ Division of Aging Services / SHIP, Monthly Premium at Age 65, male, September 2026.
Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, the state’s Blue plan, lands in the lower third for Plan G but shows no high-deductible Plan G rate. Our Blue Cross Medicare Supplement plans 2027 page explains how the Blue companies differ by state.
When Plan N or High-Deductible Plan G Beats Plan G in New Jersey
A lower premium only helps if your bills stay modest. Using the cheapest company for each plan on the New Jersey chart:
Plan G vs. Plan N. At Bankers Life, Plan N is $44.41 a month less, or $532.92 a year, about 26 office copays of $20 before ER copays or excess charges.
Same test at Horizon. Horizon’s Plan N saves $42.09 a month, or $505.08 a year.
Plan G vs. HD-G. At Bankers Life, HD-G saves $1,296.60 a year. Plan G leaves the 2027 Part B deductible of $292; HD-G leaves up to $3,050.
The crossover. Once your Medicare cost-sharing passes about $1,589 in a year, Plan G costs less in total. One hospital stay, with the $1,776 Part A deductible for 2027, clears it.
These are estimates built on 2027 CMS figures. Our Plan G vs. Plan N and high-deductible Plan G 2027 guides cover the benefits.
Under 65 in New Jersey: Plan D, Not Plan G

New Jersey law (N.J.S.A. 17B:26A-14 to 17) gives people under 65 on Medicare due to disability or kidney failure a guaranteed right to one plan: Plan D, or Plan C if they were eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Which company sells it depends on age.
| Your age | Who must sell it | Plan | Price rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under 50 | Horizon BCBS of New Jersey only (state contracted carrier) | Plan D | Same premium Horizon charges age-65 buyers |
| 50 to 64 | Any company selling Medigap in New Jersey | Plan D | Preferred rates, same as age 65 |
Sources: NJ Department of Banking and Insurance under-50 program page; NJ SHIP disability charts, 2026. Apply within 12 months of starting Part B.
Horizon’s 2026 under-50 Plan D premium is $196.16 a month for men and $181.92 for women, and other New Jersey insurers share in its losses on this group. Miss the 12-month window and a company may decline you unless a federal guaranteed-issue right applies. At 65, a new six-month window opens for any plan.
Newark ZIP Codes, Switching and Rate Changes
One company on the chart, Philadelphia American Life, charges more in parts of Newark. Zone 1 covers ZIP codes 07101-07108, 07112, 07114 and several Newark P.O. box ZIPs; Zone 2 is the rest of the state.
| Philadelphia American Life (man 65) | Newark Zone 1 | Rest of NJ | Yearly difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan N | $200.37 | $182.15 | $218.64 |
| High-deductible Plan G | $55.91 | $50.83 | $60.96 |
Our math from the NJ September 2026 chart. Other companies on the chart show one statewide age-65 rate.
No birthday rule. New Jersey has no yearly birthday or anniversary switching right, so a change outside your open enrollment usually means health questions.
Federal rights still apply. Losing a Medicare Advantage plan that leaves your area or stops serving Medicare can open a guaranteed-issue window.
Mid-year increases. The state chart notes that premiums can rise at any time of year with approval from the NJ Department of Banking and Insurance.
Fees. Some companies charge a one-time application fee, such as $20 or $25.
2027 Medicare Costs and Free Help in New Jersey
| 2027 Medicare amount | Figure | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Part B premium | $209.40 a month | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| Part B deductible | $292 | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| Part A deductible | $1,776 | CMS, Nov. 17, 2026 |
| High-deductible Plan G deductible | $3,050 | Set by CMS |
CMS announced the final 2027 Part A and B amounts on November 17, 2026.
Free state counseling: New Jersey SHIP, run by the Division of Aging Services, offers free one-on-one Medicare counseling statewide.
Plans C and F stay open only to people eligible for Medicare before 2020; others choose from G, N, high-deductible G and the remaining letters, including basic Medicare Supplement Plan A. Bills for a continuous Medigap open enrollment have been introduced in Trenton, but none has become law.
Bottom Line
On New Jersey’s September 2026 chart, the same Plan G can cost $1,627 more a year depending on the company. Plan N saves about $500 a year at low-cost companies, and high-deductible Plan G wins only in a light-use year. Under 65, the guaranteed choice is Plan D.
Get 2027 Medigap prices for your New Jersey ZIP code
New Jersey Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ What is the cheapest Plan G in New Jersey?
On the September 2026 New Jersey chart, Bankers Life (Washington National) lists the lowest Plan G for a 65-year-old man at $164.31 a month. Your quote can differ by age, sex and discounts.
➤ Who publishes Medigap rates in New Jersey?
SHIP, within the NJ Division of Aging Services, posts age-65 rate charts for men and women, plus charts for people on Medicare due to disability.
➤ Can a disabled person under 50 get a Medigap plan in New Jersey?
Yes. Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey must sell Plan D to people under 50 on Medicare who apply within 12 months of starting Part B, at its age-65 price.
➤ Can I buy Plan G before 65 in New Jersey?
The guaranteed right under 65 covers only Plan D (or Plan C for those eligible before 2020). You can buy any plan sold in New Jersey during your six-month window that starts at 65.
➤ Do Medigap prices differ inside New Jersey?
Most companies on the state chart list one age-65 rate. Philadelphia American Life charges more in Newark Zone 1 ZIP codes, about $218 a year more for Plan N.
➤ Does Horizon sell high-deductible Plan G in New Jersey?
Not according to the September 2026 chart. Horizon shows no high-deductible Plan G rate there, while 11 companies on the chart do.
➤ Is Plan N worth it in New Jersey?
At the lowest-priced companies, Plan N saves about $500 to $530 a year over Plan G. If you see doctors often or visit the ER, copays can erode that savings.
➤ Will New Jersey Medigap rates go up in 2027?
Each company files its own changes, and increases can take effect any time of year with state approval. Check the newest chart before you buy.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

