Blue Cross Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: How Your Local Blue Plan Compares
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 30, 2026
Blue Cross Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 are sold by your state’s own Blue Cross Blue Shield company, so the plans, prices and discounts depend on where you live. Every Blue company sells the same standardized plan letters, such as Plan G and Plan N, but each sets its own premiums; New Jersey’s Horizon BCBS charged $194.32 a month for Plan G for a 65-year-old man in September 2026.
2027 by the Numbers
33
independent, locally operated Blue Cross Blue Shield companies (BCBSA)
$194.32
Horizon BCBSNJ Plan G, man 65, NJ September 2026 chart
April 1
yearly Medigap rate change date at HCSC Blue plans such as BCBS of New Mexico
There is no single national Blue Cross Medigap plan. The Blue Cross Blue Shield Association licenses 33 independent companies, and each one designs, prices and services its own Medicare Supplement policies in its own territory. Florida Blue, Horizon in New Jersey and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas are all separate insurers.
That is why a Blue Cross Plan G review from another state tells you little about your price. Below we explain how the Blues work, which company covers your state, and how one Blue plan’s prices compare on official state charts. For how the plan letters differ, see our 2027 Medicare Supplement comparison chart.
Compare Blue Cross 2027 Medigap Rates
How Blue Cross Medigap Works State by State

Local companies. Each Blue company sells Medigap only where it holds the Blue license, so you can only buy from the Blue plan for your area.
Same plan letters. A Blue Plan G pays the same benefits as any other company’s Plan G, except in Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin, which use their own plan designs.
Different prices and perks. Premiums, household discounts, rate-change dates and member extras are set by each Blue company.
Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC), for example, runs the Blue plans in Illinois, Montana, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas. Highmark covers Delaware, Pennsylvania, West Virginia and parts of New York.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
Which Blue Company Sells Medigap Where You Live
| Blue company | Area it serves (examples) |
|---|---|
| Florida Blue | Florida |
| Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey | New Jersey |
| Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas (HCSC) | Texas |
| Highmark | Delaware, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, western and northeastern New York |
| Regence | Idaho, Oregon, Utah, Washington |
| Premera Blue Cross | Alaska, Washington |
From the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association company directory. Some states have more than one Blue company.
Tip: Texas’s insurance department lists “Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas, A Division of Health Care Service Corporation” among its Medigap sellers. Your own state’s insurance department list will show the exact Blue company name to look for.
Blue Cross Plan G and Plan N Prices in New Jersey
New Jersey’s Division of Aging Services publishes every Medigap company’s monthly premium. On the September 2026 chart, Horizon BCBSNJ is listed for Plan G and Plan N at age 65.
| NJ, age 65, Sept 2026 | Horizon BCBSNJ | Lowest on chart | Highest on chart |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan G, man | $194.32 | $164.31 | $299.88 |
| Plan G, woman | $179.94 | $147.88 | $260.98 |
| Plan N, man | $152.23 | $119.90 | $200.84 |
| Plan N, woman | $141.03 | $107.91 | $202.00 |
Monthly preferred rates, NJ Division of Aging Services charts revised 8/26/2026. No high-deductible Plan G was listed for Horizon.
Our math: Horizon’s Plan G for a 65-year-old man is $30.01 a month above the lowest price on the chart and $105.56 below the highest. Its Plan G costs $42.09 a month more than its own Plan N, or $505.08 a year, so a Horizon Plan N buyer would need about 25 office copays of $20 in a year before Plan G came out ahead.
Why New York Blue Plans Cost Much More

Some states require community rating, which means everyone in an area pays the same price regardless of age. New York is one of them, and its Medigap is guaranteed issue all year. Those rules spread costs across older and sicker members, so prices start much higher.
| Blue plan, Plan G | Pricing rule | Monthly price |
|---|---|---|
| Horizon BCBSNJ, man 65 (NJ) | Varies by age and gender | $194.32 |
| Highmark BlueCross BlueShield of Western New York | Community rated | $497.43 |
| Excellus BlueCross BlueShield (NY) | Community rated | $477.04 |
NY DFS comparison of community-rated Medigap premiums in effect October 1, 2026; NJ September 2026 chart.
Our math: Highmark’s Western New York Plan G costs about 2.6 times Horizon’s price for a 65-year-old New Jersey man. The trade-off is that a New Yorker can buy or switch at any age without health questions.
Blue Cross Rate Changes and Member Extras
Once-a-year changes at HCSC Blues. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico told agents its Medigap rates change once a year on April 1, with letters mailed in mid to late January.
Discounts before and after. Quoted Blue rates may be shown before any household discount, so ask for the final price.
Extras vary by company. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, for example, includes Blue365 member discounts with its Plan G and sells an optional dental, vision and hearing package.
Because these details differ by company, compare the same plan letter from your Blue plan and several other insurers. Our guide to comparing Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 walks through what to ask.
Is a Blue Cross Plan G the Right Choice for 2027?
Blue Cross Plan G pays the same as any Plan G: everything Medicare-approved after the Part B deductible, $292 for 2027. The reasons to pick the Blue version are local service, member extras and, in some states, a competitive price.
Pick Blue if. Its price for your age and ZIP is close to the lowest, and you value a locally based company.
Look elsewhere if. Another company sells the same Plan G for much less, or you want a high-deductible G your Blue plan does not offer.
Check the parent. In HCSC states, Blue Cross and HealthSpring Medigap share a parent company, so quotes from both are worth comparing.
Read more in our Plan G 2027 guide and our HealthSpring Medicare Supplement plans 2027 page.
Bottom Line
Blue Cross Medicare Supplement plans are sold by 33 separate local Blue companies, so your Blue Plan G price depends entirely on your state. On New Jersey’s September 2026 chart, Horizon’s Plan G was about $30 above the cheapest company, while community-rated Blue plans in New York cost more than twice as much. Compare your local Blue plan with other insurers for the same plan letter.
Compare your local Blue plan with other 2027 Medigap prices
Blue Cross Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ Can I buy a Blue Cross Medigap plan from another state?
No. Each Blue company sells Medigap only in its licensed area, so you buy from the Blue plan where you live. If you move, you may need a policy from that area’s Blue company or another insurer.
➤ Is Blue Cross Plan G different from other Plan G policies?
The benefits are the same because Plan G is standardized. What differs is the premium, the household discount, how often rates change and member extras like Blue365.
➤ How much is Blue Cross Plan G in New Jersey?
Horizon BCBSNJ’s Plan G was $194.32 a month for a 65-year-old man and $179.94 for a 65-year-old woman on the September 2026 state chart.
➤ When do Blue Cross Medigap rates go up?
It depends on the company. HCSC Blue plans such as Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico change rates once a year on April 1, with notices mailed in January.
➤ Why are Blue Cross supplements so expensive in New York?
New York requires community rating and year-round guaranteed issue, so everyone pays the same price regardless of age or health. In October 2026, Blue Plan G prices there were around $477 to $497 a month.
➤ Does Blue Cross offer high-deductible Plan G?
Some Blue companies do and some do not. Horizon BCBSNJ, for example, had no high-deductible G on New Jersey’s September 2026 chart.
➤ How many Blue Cross Blue Shield companies are there?
The Blue Cross Blue Shield Association describes 33 independent, community-based and locally operated companies covering all 50 states, Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico.
➤ Is Blue Cross Medigap the same company as HealthSpring?
Not exactly. In Illinois, Montana, New Mexico, Oklahoma and Texas, both are owned by Health Care Service Corporation, but they sell separate Medigap policies with their own prices.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

