Indiana Medicare Supplement Plans 2027: The State List, Pending Rate Requests and the Birthday Rule
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 6, 2026
Indiana Medicare Supplement plans for 2027 are sold by the 35 companies on the Indiana Department of Insurance’s September 24, 2026 SHIP list, and 33 of them offer Plan G. Since January 1, 2026, Indiana members age 65 and older can also move to the same plan letter at a different company each year around their birthday without health questions.
2027 by the Numbers
35
companies on the Indiana SHIP Medigap list, Rev. 9-24-26 (our count)
15%
median increase requested in 45 pending 2026 Indiana filings for current-plan policies (our math, IDOI Rate Watch)
370,851
Indiana Medigap enrollees in 2023 (AHIP data via healthinsurance.org)
200%
most an insurer may charge under-65 buyers for most plans, compared with its age-65 rate (SEA 215)
Indiana does not post a printable price chart for Medigap. The Department of Insurance keeps a list of approved companies and the plan letters each one sells, and its premium comparison tool sits behind a sign-in page. The state does publish something most shopping guides overlook: Rate Watch, a public log of every rate change insurers ask for.
This guide counts the latest company list, sums up the 2026 rate requests now waiting for a state decision, and explains two newer Indiana laws on switching and under-65 access. For a plan-by-plan view of benefits, see our Medicare Supplement plans comparison chart 2027.
Check 2027 Indiana Plan G Prices
35 Companies on Indiana's September 2026 Medigap List

Indiana SHIP, part of the Department of Insurance, revised its list of companies approved to sell standardized Medigap policies on September 24, 2026. We counted 35 names and tallied the plan letters printed next to each one.
| Plan letter | Companies selling it in Indiana | Who can buy it |
|---|---|---|
| Plan G | 33 of 35 | Anyone new to Medicare |
| Plan N | 32 of 35 | Anyone new to Medicare |
| Plan A | 33 of 35 | Anyone new to Medicare |
| High-deductible Plan G | 10 of 35 | Anyone new to Medicare |
| Plan K / Plan L | 5 of 35 | Anyone new to Medicare |
| Plan F | 32 of 35 | Only people eligible for Medicare before 2020 |
Our count from the Indiana SHIP Medicare Supplements list, Rev. 9-24-26. Each company picks its own plan letters and service areas.
Indiana-only option. Indiana Farm Bureau Health Plans sells Plans A, B, C, D, F, G, M and N.
Blue Cross plan. Anthem Insurance Company appears with Plans A, F, G and N.
National names. Mutual of Omaha, Aetna, Humana, UnitedHealthcare, State Farm and USAA Life are all on the list.
Filing fine print: The list changes during the year. Medico Corp Life appeared on the August 11, 2026 edition but not on the September 24 edition, and Cigna has a pending Indiana rate filing yet is not on the list. A ZIP-code quote shows which companies sell where you live.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
What Insurers Asked Indiana to Approve for 2026-2027
Rate Watch shows each company, the date it filed and the overall percentage it requested. Filings marked MS08I cover individual policies sold under the current plan letters, including Plan G and Plan N. We reviewed the 45 of these submitted in 2026 that were still waiting for a state decision in early November.
| Company (Rate Watch name) | Filed | Requested change |
|---|---|---|
| Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company | Nov. 4, 2026 | 0.0% |
| Humana Insurance Company | Aug. 6, 2026 | 9.5% and 7.4% (two filings) |
| Wisconsin Physicians Service | July 24, 2026 | 11.0% |
| HealthSpring Insurance Company | Sept. 29, 2026 | 12.9% |
| Medico Insurance Company | July 21, 2026 | 15.1% |
| Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company | July 1, 2026 | 22.0% |
| National Health Insurance Company | Sept. 24, 2026 | 39.4% (highest request) |
Source: Indiana Department of Insurance Rate Watch, MS08I filings, viewed November 2026. Requests are not approvals, and each figure is an overall average across the filing.
Our math across all 45 pending filings: the median request is 15%, 14 companies asked for 20% or more, and three asked for no change. Your own change can differ by plan, age and area. Our Medicare Supplement rate increases 2027 guide explains how insurers justify these requests.
Medicare Before 65: SEA 215 Opened Every Plan
Indiana once required insurers to sell only Plan A to people under 65. Senate Enrolled Act 215, effective January 1, 2025, changed that. Any Medigap plan an insurer sells to people with Medicare must now also be offered to people who have Medicare because of a disability or end-stage renal disease.
Six-month window. It starts on the first day of the month your Medicare begins. People already on Medicare under 65 before 2025 had a one-time window from January 1 to June 30, 2025.
No health screening. Insurers cannot deny you or set conditions based on health status, claims or medical history, and cannot add a pre-existing condition wait.
Price ceiling for Plans A, B and D. The premium cannot be higher than the insurer’s age-65 rate for the same policy.
Price ceiling for other plans. For Plan G, Plan N and the rest, the premium can be up to 200% of the age-65 rate.
Example of the cap, using made-up round numbers: if a company charges a 65-year-old $150 a month for Plan G, it may charge an under-65 buyer up to $300. If its Plan A costs $120 at 65, the under-65 price can be no higher than $120. Details on that plan are in our Medicare Supplement Plan A 2027 guide.
Indiana's Birthday Rule: Same Letter, New Company

House Enrolled Act 1226 created Indiana’s birthday rule, effective January 1, 2026. If you are 65 or older and already hold a Medigap policy, a company cannot turn you down or medically underwrite you when you switch to its version of the same plan letter during your yearly window.
| Switch | Covered by the birthday rule? |
|---|---|
| Plan G at one company to Plan G at another | Yes |
| High-deductible Plan G to standard Plan G | Yes, SHIP treats it as the same letter |
| Plan F to Plan G | No, different letters |
| Under 65 on a Medigap policy | No, the rule starts at 65 |
| No Medigap policy today | No, you must already be enrolled |
Source: Indiana SHIP HEA 1226 fact sheet and AskSHIP column, July 2026. Insurers may still price by age, gender, ZIP code and tobacco use.
Hoosier timing check: The window runs from one month before your birthday to one month after it. The new policy starts on the first day of the month after you sign, so an application signed June 15 begins July 1. Cancel the old policy only after the new one is approved.
Is High-Deductible Plan G Worth It in Indiana? Our Break-Even Math
Ten companies on the state list sell high-deductible Plan G. For 2027 it pays nothing until you meet a $3,050 deductible, set by CMS. Standard Plan G members still pay the Part B deductible, projected at $292, so the most extra you could pay on the high-deductible version in a bad year is $2,758.
| Monthly premium savings | Yearly savings | Worst-case extra cost | Worst-case net |
|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $720 | $2,758 | $2,038 more |
| $100 | $1,200 | $2,758 | $1,558 more |
| $150 | $1,800 | $2,758 | $958 more |
| $230 | $2,760 | $2,758 | About even |
Our calculation: $3,050 deductible minus the projected $292 Part B deductible that standard Plan G members also pay. Savings levels are examples, not Indiana quotes.
In a low-claim year, the high-deductible plan keeps all of the premium savings. More detail is on our high-deductible Plan G 2027 page.
Budget Figures for 2027 and Free Counseling for Hoosiers
Part B premium. $209.50 a month in 2027, a Trustees projection, up from $202.90 in 2026.
Part B deductible. $292 for 2027. No plan sold to people new to Medicare covers it.
Part A deductible. $1,788 per benefit period, projected. Plans G and N pay it.
Plan K and Plan L limits. $8,360 and $4,180 in 2027, set by CMS.
Indiana SHIP offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling and can run Medigap comparisons with the state’s tool. Your first six months on Part B at 65 or older remain the safest time to buy, as our Medicare Supplement open enrollment 2027 guide explains.
Bottom Line
Indiana shoppers can pick from 35 listed companies, and 33 of them sell Plan G. With most pending rate requests in double digits, the new birthday rule gives members 65 and older a yearly chance to compare the same plan letter at other companies without health questions.
See Indiana Medigap prices for your ZIP code
Indiana Medicare Supplement Plans 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ Does Indiana publish a Medigap premium chart?
Not as a printable chart. The SHIP list of companies points shoppers to the Department of Insurance’s online comparison tool, which requires a sign-in, and SHIP counselors can run comparisons for you.
➤ How many companies sell Plan G in Indiana?
Our count of the September 24, 2026 SHIP list shows 33 of 35 companies selling Plan G. The two exceptions sell only high-deductible Plan G.
➤ Where can I see Indiana Medigap rate increase requests?
Rate Watch, on the Department of Insurance website, lists each filing with the company, filing date, status and requested percentage.
➤ Did Mutual of Omaha ask for an Indiana rate increase?
Its November 4, 2026 filing on Rate Watch shows a 0.0% requested change.
➤ Can I switch Medigap companies on my birthday in Indiana?
Yes, if you are 65 or older and already have a Medigap policy. You can move to the same plan letter at another company from one month before to one month after your birthday.
➤ Can I change from Plan F to Plan G under the birthday rule?
No. The rule covers only the same plan letter, though SHIP counts a move from high-deductible Plan G to standard Plan G as the same letter.
➤ Can I buy Plan G in Indiana if I am under 65?
Yes. Since January 1, 2025, insurers must offer every plan they sell to people with Medicare due to disability or ESRD during a six-month window, with premiums for most plans capped at twice the age-65 rate.
➤ How many Hoosiers have a Medicare Supplement plan?
AHIP counted 370,851 Indiana Medigap enrollees in 2023, as reported by healthinsurance.org.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

