Medicare Supplement Plans Utah 2027: The New Birthday Rule, Company Prices and the Under-65 Gap
Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 10, 2026
Medicare Supplement plans in Utah for 2027 cost about $137 to $284 a month for Plan G at age 65 on broker rate data from July 2026, and since May 2025 Utah’s birthday rule gives you 60 days after each birthday to move to a comparable or lower plan with your current company without health questions. High-deductible Plan G starts near $41 a month.
2027 by the Numbers
60 days
yearly birthday window under Utah’s 2025 HB 258
$172 / $206
EMI Health Plan G, woman / man 65, rates effective 4/1/2026
81,726
Utahns with Medigap in 2023 (AHIP)
$1,764
yearly Plan G gap between low and high companies at 65 (our math)
Utah’s Medigap rules changed recently. A 2025 law added a birthday rule, and a 2026 bill that would have opened Medigap to people under 65 did not pass. Prices also spread widely: the same standardized Plan G can cost twice as much at one company as at another.
The Utah Insurance Department points shoppers to its online Medigap comparison tool rather than a printed chart. This guide pulls together the state rules, a filed Utah rate table from a local insurer, a company-by-company price list and our own cost math. For the coverage side of the decision, see our Plan G vs Plan N comparison.
Compare Utah 2027 Medigap Rates
Utah's Birthday Rule, in Effect Since 2025

House Bill 258, Medicare Supplement Insurance Amendments, took effect May 7, 2025, and is now part of Utah Code section 31A-22-620. Each year, for 60 days starting on your birthday, your current insurer must let you move to a plan of comparable or lower benefits without medical underwriting.
Same company only. The switch stays with your current insurer. Utah does not require insurers to offer plans from affiliated companies.
Sideways or down. Plan G to Plan N or high-deductible Plan G qualifies. Moving up to a richer plan does not.
No anniversary rule. Utah has no rule for switching to a new company on your policy anniversary.
Rating method matters. Most Utah companies use attained-age rating, so your price rises as you age, per the Insurance Department.
Timing note: If your 2027 renewal brings a large increase, the birthday window is the cleanest way to move to Plan N or high-deductible Plan G at the same company without answering health questions.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll
Plan G, Plan N and HD-G Prices by Company
These monthly premiums come from a broker’s Utah rate list marked current as of July 2026, for a 65-year-old non-tobacco buyer. The list shows each company’s lowest rate; several sell more than one tier. Educators Mutual’s figure matches EMI Health’s filed rate for a 65-year-old woman.
| Company | Plan G | Plan N | HD Plan G |
|---|---|---|---|
| LifeShield National | $137 | $101 | – |
| Insurance Co. of North America (Cigna) | $155 | $107 | $52 |
| State Farm | $156 | $119 | – |
| Educators Mutual (EMI Health) | $172 | – | – |
| Aetna Health and Life | $213 | $147 | – |
| Humana | $229 | $172 | $41 |
| Regence BlueCross BlueShield of Utah | $233 | $205 | – |
| Omaha Insurance Co. (Mutual of Omaha) | $284 | $152 | $42 |
Source: unitedmedicareadvisors.com Utah rate data, current as of July 2026, age 65, non-tobacco, monthly. A dash means no rate was listed. Confirm with medigap.utah.gov or a quote.
Our math: LifeShield and Mutual of Omaha are $147 a month apart for the same Plan G, or $1,764 a year. Plan N savings range from $28 a month at Regence to $132 a month at Mutual of Omaha, so the plan letter that wins depends on the company.
A Filed Utah Rate Table: EMI Health Plan G by Age
EMI Health, the Utah-based insurer behind Educators Mutual, publishes its Plan G rates by age and sex in its 2026 Senior Products brochure, effective April 1, 2026. It is a rare look at a full Utah age curve from the insurer itself.
| EMI Health Plan G, monthly | Woman | Man | Man pays more by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Age 65 | $172 | $206 | $408 a year |
| Age 70 | $218 | $261 | $516 a year |
| Age 75 | $255 | $305 | $600 a year |
| Age 80 | $279 | $334 | $660 a year |
| Age 85 | $295 | $353 | $696 a year |
Source: EMI Health 2026 Senior Products brochure, rates effective 4/1/2026. Yearly differences are our math. EMI offers a 5% household discount.
Our math: EMI’s Plan G rises 71.5% for women and 71.4% for men from 65 to 85, before any rate increases. The steepest step is 65 to 70, about 27%. Ask other companies for their age-75 price too, since curves differ. Our Medicare Plan G cost 2027 guide explains the three rating methods.
Our Math: High-Deductible Plan G in Utah

High-deductible Plan G premiums in Utah are low, starting at $41 a month at Humana on the July 2026 list. For 2027 the deductible is $3,050, set by CMS, and it includes the Part B deductible.
| Humana, age 65 | HD Plan G | Regular Plan G |
|---|---|---|
| Yearly premium | $492 | $2,748 |
| Healthy year (Part B deductible only, projected $292) | $784 | $3,040 |
| Worst case (full deductible met) | $3,542 | $3,040 |
Our math using the July 2026 list prices. HD Plan G worst case = premium + $3,050. Regular Plan G = premium + projected $292 Part B deductible.
At Humana, high-deductible Plan G saves $2,256 in a healthy year and costs at most $502 more in a bad one. That math is unusually favorable. Our high-deductible Plan G 2027 guide shows how to test it with your own numbers.
Under 65 and on Medicare in Utah
No state requirement. Utah does not require insurers to sell Medigap to people under 65. The Insurance Department warns you may be unable to buy a policy if you are under 65 with a disability or ESRD.
A 2026 fix that failed. HB 340 would have guaranteed under-65 access within 180 days of Medicare enrollment. Its enacting clause was struck on March 6, 2026.
Very few options. As of June 2026, Medicare.gov listed one insurer offering under-65 plans in Utah, according to healthinsurance.org.
Your 65 reset. At 65 you get the standard six-month Medigap open enrollment with no health questions.
Our Medicare Supplement plans under 65 page shows which states do guarantee access.
Getting Ready for 2027 in Utah
Know the market. Utah had 465,601 Medicare beneficiaries in 2024, 51.8% in Medicare Advantage (KFF), and 81,726 Medigap enrollees in 2023 (AHIP).
Plan for the 2027 figures. CMS set a $292 Part B deductible and a $209.40 Part B premium for 2027. CMS sets the official amounts each fall.
Watch tobacco pricing. The Insurance Department says smokers may pay up to 20% more, and a pre-existing condition waiting period can last up to six months outside open enrollment.
Get free help. Utah’s SHIP, run with the Division of Aging and Adult Services through local Area Agencies on Aging, offers free counseling.
Living near the Arizona line? Compare our Arizona Medicare Supplement plans 2027 page; your premium follows your home address.
Bottom Line
Medicare Supplement plans in Utah for 2027 differ by about $1,764 a year for the same Plan G at 65, and high-deductible Plan G is unusually cheap. The 2025 birthday rule now gives Utah policyholders a yearly, no-questions way to step down to a lower-cost plan with their current company.
See Utah Plan G, Plan N and HD-G prices for your ZIP code
Medicare Supplement Plans Utah 2027 — Frequently Asked Questions
➤ Does Utah have a Medigap birthday rule?
Yes. Since May 7, 2025, Utah law gives you 60 days starting on your birthday each year to move to a comparable or lower plan with your current insurer without medical underwriting.
➤ Can I use Utah’s birthday rule to change companies?
No. The switch stays with your current insurer, and Utah does not require it to offer plans from affiliated companies.
➤ How much is Plan G in Utah?
On July 2026 broker data for a 65-year-old non-smoker, Plan G ran from about $137 to $284 a month. EMI Health’s filed rate was $172 for a woman and $206 for a man at 65.
➤ Can I buy Medigap in Utah if I’m under 65?
Utah does not require insurers to sell to people under 65, so choices are very limited. A 2026 bill to change this did not pass.
➤ Is high-deductible Plan G worth it in Utah?
It can be. At Humana’s $41 a month, our math shows it costs at most about $502 more than regular Plan G in a bad year and saves about $2,256 in a healthy one.
➤ Where can I compare Medigap prices in Utah?
The Utah Insurance Department links to its medigap.utah.gov comparison tool. A licensed agent can also quote several companies at once.
➤ Do smokers pay more for Medigap in Utah?
Often. The Utah Insurance Department says smokers may pay up to 20% more.
➤ How many Utahns have a Medicare Supplement plan?
AHIP counted 81,726 Medigap enrollees in Utah in 2023, out of roughly 466,000 Medicare beneficiaries.
Compare Medicare Supplement Plans
Call a Licensed Agent Now
Compare 2027 Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.
No obligation to enroll

